Welcome to a world of sweets and treats: we’re always baking up new, fantastic flavors for our cupcakes. If you have suggestions for a flavor, email us at cupcakemagician@yahoo.com. We’d love to hear from you! 

  • Mini Cupcakes: $1.25 ( Mini cupcakes are made by order only; we request you order a minimum of 6 of each flavor. Please call 48 hours ahead.)
  • Cupcakes $2.50
  • Select Cupcakes $2.75 cannoli, chocolate cannoli, pancake bacon, cookie dough, banana cream pie, and select seasonal specialties.
  • Gluten-Free Cupcakes: $3 (call ahead for today's flavors (732) 530-5700.) 

Check out our custom cakes and cupcakes! Call for pricing. We can also bake gluten free cakes upon request. 

* Stuffed- Magically stuffed cupcakes.

OO/ Order Only- Minimum of 6 per flavor when ordering. 

S/ Seasonal - Only available in season.